top of page
Search

Pitching Your Startup to Candidates: What Founders Get Wrong

Updated: 3 days ago

ree


Why This Matters

Investor decks get precision. Hiring pitches get leftovers. Top candidates have options and evaluate leadership, upside, and how thoughtfully you run the process. If your message sounds vague or chaotic, they move on. You need a crisp story that shows real traction and why the role matters now.


What Founders Often Get Wrong


  1. Too much product, not enough market

    1. Candidates want proof you solve a paid problem for a specific buyer, not just cool tech.

    2. Flip it: We help [specific role] achieve [measurable outcome] without [industry pain]. There is no clear category leader yet.


  2. Leading with chaos, not clarity

    1. Early stage is expected. Signaling disorder is avoidable.

    2. Flip it: You will help shape how we sell, not just follow a playbook, and we will build it together.


  3. Pitching like you are doing them a favor

    1. Top sellers want upside, ownership, momentum. Vague or unprepared kills interest.

    2. Flip it: Here is what we have done, what is next, and where you will make the difference.


What Great Pitches Include

  • Role ownership plus room to build: Clear scope and the freedom to shape it.

  • Momentum without hype: Simple proof points and what is happening next.

  • Why this role matters: Tie the work to outcomes the company cannot hit without it.


Tailor the Pitch to the Role


For AEs, especially founding AEs

  • Own a segment or territory

  • Pipeline reality and support, stated plainly

  • High impact mandate

  • Equity, mentorship, visibility to product and leadership


Example: You will be our first AE. We have warm leads from founder led sales, a defined ICP, and you will help build the repeatable process. You will have a seat at the table as we shape GTM.


For Player Coaches

Senior ICs who want autonomy now and a path to leadership.

  • Short term ownership with long term upside

  • Honest team growth timeline

  • Your coaching style or plan to hire one


Example: You will sell first, but you are not capped there. We plan to hire two more reps in 6 to 9 months and will lean on you to shape that team.


For SDRs

  • ICP clarity and strong value props

  • Training, enablement, and leadership exposure

  • Examples of career paths from this seat


Example: You will work with the founder and AE to target our most active ICP. This role is high visibility and sets you up to grow into closing or strategy roles.


For CSMs or AMs

  • How the role supports growth and expansion

  • Touchpoints with product, CS leadership, and sales

  • Ownership across onboarding, retention, or upsell


Example: You will own onboarding and early adoption for every new customer. You will help shape our first QBR process and be the voice of the customer to product.


Final Thought

The best candidates evaluate conviction and clarity. A good pitch invites the right people to lean in and self select. Speak in candidate value, not investor headlines.


About ClosedWon Talent

ClosedWon Talent is a specialized sales recruiting firm that helps growth focused companies hire top GTM talent. We partner with founders, revenue leaders, and investors to build high performing sales teams across SaaS and beyond.


What sets us apart is the ClosedWon Method, a proven recruiting framework built on speed, precision, and transparency. We combine deep industry expertise with a curated candidate network to deliver shortlists of qualified, motivated sales professionals fast. Our team does not just fill roles, we act as embedded partners who understand how to assess selling style, territory experience, and growth potential based on each clients' specific needs.


bottom of page